In researching reasons someone might be admitted to an insane asylum in 1900, I came across lists in various superintendent log books and yearly reports that left me either laughing or shaking my head. Clearly, doctors in the late 19th century did not view mental illness the way we do today.
In our post-Freudian culture of psychoanalysis and scientific enlightenment, a list that includes epileptics, alcoholics and the mentally handicapped among the insane seems somehow wrong. Even more troubling are causes like menopause, overwork, religion, and cigarettes. What helped me make some sense of it all was the understanding that most 19th-century doctors believed insanity could be caused by moral factors as well as physical ones. Also, as with many diseases of the day, they believed heredity played a large part in whether a person was more susceptible to going insane. Thus, statements like “doubt about mother’s ancestors” became a little more clear to me. (I’ve had a few doubts about my own ancestors, but hopefully that won’t lead to my eventual insanity.)
It also helped to read the case histories in addition to the cause listed for a patient’s admittance. For the most part, people were committed to insane asylums because they acted, well, insane. Though these lists can cause my novel-writing mind to kick into overdrive with all sorts of sinister scenarios, the woman who was committed for “religious enthusiasm” was most likely there because she believed herself to be the Mother of Jesus or an avenging angel of some kind.
Still, there was the case of Elizabeth Packard who spent three years in an insane asylum because she disagreed with her husband’s religious beliefs. And if it could happen to her, who’s to say it couldn’t have happened to someone else given the right circumstances, a believable motive and a few dastardly antagonists? . . . and a novel is born.
In case you are interested in getting your own creative juices flowing, check out this list from the late 1800s and this one from the turn of the century. Meanwhile, here’s a sampling of a few causes I’ve been puzzling over:
- Asthma
- Superstition
- Gathering in the head (who or what is doing this gathering?)
- Remorse
- Politics
- Pecuniary losses: worms (really not seeing a connection here)
- Laziness
- Novel reading
Reblogged this on The Blogspaper.
Religious disagreement within the home…hmmm. Not something I’d know anything about. But with over a dozen Presbyterian ministers (living or dead) related to me or my wife I could see where excessive religious AGREEMENT within a family could cause some trouble.
Great idea for a blog, Kathy. I look forward to following it (and to the novel).
Thanks, Jim. I’ve enjoyed following your blog too.
Kathleen, Have you read Kathleen Eagle’s Sunrise Song about the Asylum for Insane Indians in Canton, SD? People were sent there for no other reason than they were “difficult”, as in, asking too many questions about where their money went.
I just finished The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks. Her daughter was locked up in the Crownsville, MD asylum without any diagnosis – her only problem might have been deafness. Scary!
I have not read that one. Sounds interesting (and sad). I did read where the indigent were often sent to Asylums because they had no where else to go, especially if they were immigrants with a language barrier.